Tuesday, July 02, 2013
Edie Middlestein is at the center of this story and her battles with her weight form a framework on which Attenberg hangs the rest of the tale. Attenberg hops around in time as she tells Edie’s story, using Edie’s varying mass as signposts. Overweight as a child, for Edie, food is love, hand delivered by her doting mother. As a young woman Edie reduces to a fashionable weight but food becomes the enemy, and by middle age it’s a weapon. Attenberg carefully dissects the cultural implications of food in a 20th century American immigrant family but never overdoes it. And she uses humor and wry observations to show that everyone is obsessed with something. Edie’s children Benny and Robin abuse marijuana and alcohol, and her controlling daughter-in-law (perhaps in response to Edie’s ballooning weight) forces her family to live on raw vegetables and tofu – the scenes of her husband and children’s reactions to this are some of the funniest in the book. Indeed, the humor in this book kind of creeps up on you. I wasn’t expecting to laugh out loud but I did, often. But I wasn’t laughing AT the Middlesteins; Attenberg never demeans her characters by making them the butt of jokes. It’s LIFE that makes you laugh, that is, unless it makes you cry.
(Book 18, 2013)